The Beguines: The Medieval Women Who Refused to Be Nuns or Wives (And Lasted 800 Years)

by Heather  - November 20, 2026

The last Beguine died in 2013. Her name was Marcella Pattyn, she was 92 years old, and she had been living as a Beguine since 1941. When she died in Kortrijk, Belgium, an 800-year-old movement officially came to an end. And I think most of us had no idea it had been going on in the first place!

So let’s fix that, because the Beguines are one of those stories where the more you learn, the more you can’t believe nobody told you about them sooner. Here’s the video, or keep scrolling for the written version.

Who were the Beguines?

Picture yourself as a woman in northwestern Europe in the 13th century who wants to live a religious life. You have two options. You can get married, which means your spiritual life is largely your husband’s business. Or you can enter a convent, which means paying what was basically a dowry to the Church, submitting to a strict rule, taking permanent vows, and never leaving. That’s it. The medieval Church had a very tidy system, and women fit into it in exactly two ways.

Some women looked at those two options and said no, thank you, we’ll figure something else out. And they did. They became the Beguines.

The movement started in the Low Countries, what’s now Belgium and the Netherlands, in the early 13th century, and nobody planned it. Women in different cities started doing the same thing independently, at almost the same time. They clustered their homes around a church, prayed and studied together, and supported themselves, usually by working in the cloth trade. They didn’t take permanent vows and they weren’t cloistered. They could leave whenever they wanted, including to get married, with no penalty at all.

The communities they built were called beguinages (begijnhofs in Flemish), and some of them are still standing. I’ll come back to that, because it’s a deeply satisfying ending.

Why did the Church find the Beguines so threatening?

The Beguines sat in a category the medieval world didn’t have a word for. They weren’t nuns, they weren’t wives, and they weren’t hermits either. A Franciscan friar named Gilbert of Tournai wrote about them in 1274, and you can almost hear his confusion curdling into hostility in real time. He said there were women among them whom nobody knew what to call, ordinary women or nuns, because they lived neither in the world nor out of it. He meant that as a problem. I think it sounds more like a compliment.

Join us at Tudorcon From Home

Beyond how they lived, there was what they were doing with their time. They were studying and writing, and they were doing it in French and Flemish instead of Latin. That matters more than it sounds. Latin was the language of the Church, of scholarship and of authority, and most women were never formally taught it. Writing theology in Flemish or French meant writing theology that ordinary people, women included, could actually read. It chipped away at the idea that you needed an institution standing between you and God. (Three hundred years later, people in England would still be fighting about exactly this over English Bibles.)

One Beguine, Hadewijch of Antwerp, wrote something I want you to hear.

Men try to dissuade me from everything that love bids me do. They don’t understand it, and I can’t explain it to them. I must live out what I am.

She was writing about mystical union with God. She was also describing, 800 years ago and with total clarity, what it feels like to be a woman whose inner life makes no sense to the people around her.

The Beguines were hugely popular in the early decades. Ghent alone had thousands of them at its peak. They were part of the same wave that produced St Francis, a hunger for a simpler, more direct experience of God outside the big institutions. There was a practical side too. The Crusades had taken huge numbers of men, and in some regions women seem to have outnumbered men by a lot, so becoming a Beguine gave women an option that otherwise wouldn’t have existed.

But popularity made them visible, and for a group of women outside institutional control, visible was dangerous. What the male clergy couldn’t categorize, they could call heretical, and they did. A woman pursuing holiness without a bishop or an abbot or a husband supervising her was, pretty much by definition, suspicious. Accusations of heresy started to appear, and with them came the Inquisition. Not the Spanish one (nobody expects that one), but the earlier medieval Inquisition that Pope Gregory IX set up in the 1230s. Several Beguines were burned alive. Others were harassed and their communities broken up, as the Church kept trying to either absorb them into formal religious orders or get rid of them entirely.

Marguerite Porete and The Mirror of Simple Souls

Then came 1310, and the case that put all of this into the sharpest possible focus.

Marguerite Porete was a Beguine from the county of Hainaut, in what’s now Belgium. Around 1300 she wrote a book called The Mirror of Simple Souls, a work of mystical theology arguing that the soul could become so completely united with God that it moved beyond the need for the Church’s structures. She wasn’t saying the Church was bad, or that the sacraments were worthless. She was saying that in the highest states of union with God, the soul simply went past them. You can see why that was going to be a problem.

The Bishop of Cambrai condemned the book and had it publicly burned in front of her. She was ordered to stop distributing it. She kept distributing it! She even sent copies to respected theologians looking for their endorsement, including Godfrey of Fontaines, a master of theology at the University of Paris. She didn’t get the support she was hoping for, and the Inquisition took her into custody.

This is the part I keep coming back to. For a year and a half, Marguerite sat before the Inquisition and said nothing. She didn’t recant and she didn’t defend herself. She refused to take the oath to answer their questions, which under inquisitorial procedure meant she could be convicted on the strength of her book alone. She knew that, and she stayed silent anyway. She was convicted of relapsed heresy and burned at the stake in Paris on 1 June 1310. Witnesses said she was so composed that many people in the crowd wept.

They thought they were erasing her book. They weren’t. Copies had already been made, and they circulated anonymously in French, Latin, Italian and Middle English. For centuries scholars read The Mirror of Simple Souls without knowing who wrote it, and it got attributed to various male mystics. Then in 1946 a scholar named Romana Guarnieri identified Marguerite as the author. The book is still in print. You can go and buy it today.

How did the Beguines survive for 800 years?

The Council of Vienne, which met from 1311 to 1312, officially condemned the Beguines as heretics. Its decree described their discussions of theology as an intolerable presumption. Intolerable presumption!

And the Beguines just kept going. This is the part I find almost funny, in the best way. The Church threw everything at them over the centuries, condemnation and dispersal and the Inquisition and formal decrees, and they outlasted all of it. Some communities went underground. Some found protection from more sympathetic local bishops. Some simply carried on in places where nobody with authority was paying close attention. By the 17th and 18th centuries the movement was smaller but still there, and by the 19th century the Belgian beguinages were being recognized as architectural and cultural heritage.

Marcella Pattyn joined in 1941, outlived every other Beguine, and died in 2013 at 92, the last living link to 800 years of women who decided to live on their own terms.

Can you visit a beguinage today?

Yes! The Flemish beguinages, including the ones in Bruges and Ghent, are UNESCO World Heritage Sites, and Amsterdam’s Begijnhof is still standing too. Tourists wander through them and people get married in their churches. The spaces these women built, which the Church tried over and over to dismantle, are now considered irreplaceable human heritage. If you ever find yourself in Belgium, the beguinage in Bruges is extraordinary.

Sign up on Patreon

I think about Hadewijch writing in Flemish in the 13th century, “I must live out what I am.” I think about Marguerite sitting in silence for 18 months while the Inquisition tried to make her take it back. And I think about all the women in Ghent and Bruges and Amsterdam whose names we’ll never know, who just kept showing up every day while the institutions argued about whether they were allowed to exist. They didn’t wait for permission. They kept going, and in the end, they won.

Books about the Beguines

If you want to read more, I’d start with The Mirror of Simple Souls by Marguerite Porete herself. It’s very readable, and very strange in the best possible way. For the historical deep dive, Tanya Stabler Miller’s The Beguines of Medieval Paris is wonderful. And if you want to go way back, I first wrote about the Beguines on this blog back in 2014, and then promptly forgot about them until a listener asked for this episode.

This episode came out of a listener’s comment on my video about convents, so if you want the other side of the story, here’s why smart Tudor women chose the convent, and what Henry VIII took from them.

Would you have joined the Beguines? Honestly, I think I’d have loved it. Tell me in the comments on the video.

If you love stories like this, I send one to your inbox every week. Sign up for the newsletter here.

Dive Deeper!

Join the Free tudor Learning Circle! The Only Social Network for Tudor nerds!

What If Katherine of Aragon Had Agreed to the Annulment?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}

You may be interested in