Okay, picture this. Your family just lost a civil war. Your brothers are probably dead in the Tower, and nobody’s talking about it. Your uncle, who grabbed the throne when your father died, has just been killed at Bosworth. The new king has married your older sister, which is fine, that part worked out. But you’re still a Yorkist princess with royal blood, which in 1485 is basically a target painted on your back.
You could wait and see which husband gets picked for you, and hope he isn’t awful, and hope you survive the pregnancies, and hope you don’t end up on the wrong side of the next political crisis. Or you could go to Dartford Priory. That’s what Bridget of York, the youngest daughter of Edward IV, chose. And I need you to know before we go any further that this was not a consolation prize. It was a deliberate and arguably brilliant decision. Here’s the video, or keep scrolling for the written version.
Were Tudor women forced into convents?
When most people picture a Tudor noblewoman ending up in a convent, they imagine something like a prison sentence. She didn’t get a good marriage offer, she was inconvenient, so she got shipped off. And look, that definitely happened. Plenty of families used convents exactly that way, as somewhere to put daughters they couldn’t afford to marry off properly.
But that framing misses something big. Even for the women who didn’t choose it, the convent often turned out to be better than the alternative. And for the women who did choose it, they were choosing something remarkable.
What was life like at Dartford Priory?
Dartford, in Kent, was the only Dominican nunnery in England, and it had a reputation for scholarship and a strict religious life. To get in, you had to be able to read, or at least be capable of learning. This was not a dumping ground. It was a place that took its intellectual life seriously. Bridget’s grandmother, Cecily Neville, left her books in her will, including lives of holy women and saints. And Thomas More, who wasn’t exactly in the habit of handing out compliments, specifically praised Bridget’s virtue and devotion.
What did a convent offer Tudor women?
First, no husband and no pregnancies. In a world where childbirth killed women all the time, that’s huge. Bridget’s sister, Queen Elizabeth of York, Henry VII’s wife, died after childbirth at 37. Bridget, tucked away at Dartford, almost certainly outlived her. Just sit with that for a minute.
Second, and this one surprised me, there was real leadership. Abbesses ran real institutions. They managed estates, handled legal relationships, employed staff and oversaw the money. At Barking Abbey in Essex, one of the great royal nunneries, the nuns held offices with real responsibility, and those offices were reviewed every year. If you did well you got promoted, and if you didn’t, you got moved down. There was an actual career structure! One prioress at Barking held her post for 30 years.
And abbesses were elected. All the nuns voted. Candidates had to be at least 21, of legitimate birth and of good reputation, and what decided it was wisdom and ability. Women in medieval and Tudor England choosing their own leader on merit! You don’t find that in many places in this period.
Third, stability. These women had known each other for decades. They had a community, a daily structure, and a sense of purpose that didn’t depend on a husband’s fortunes or a king’s favor. Compare that with the alternative. You were married off young, pregnant every year or two, legally under your husband’s control, and if he ended up on the wrong side of politics, you went down with him. If he died, you depended on his family’s goodwill. The convent gave women something the outside world almost never did, which was continuity.
Why did Bridget of York become a nun?
Bridget is the clearest example I found of a woman who actively chose the convent, and I find her story oddly moving. When Henry VII was making marriage plans for his wife’s younger sisters, he apparently considered Bridget as a bride for the heir to the Scottish throne. And Bridget said no thank you, she wanted to be a nun. Henry’s mother, Lady Margaret Beaufort, supported her, and Bridget went to Dartford.
She spent pretty much her whole life there. She left only a handful of times, once for her mother’s funeral in 1492 and at least once for a sister’s. She wrote to her sister the queen, who sent her money for small expenses and wrote in 1502 asking after her health and asking her to pray for the family. When Elizabeth died the next year, those letters stopped. Bridget died sometime around 1513 to 1517 and was buried in the choir of the priory church.
She came in as a little girl whose family had been torn apart by 30 years of civil war. Her father was dead, her brothers were gone, and her family had been declared illegitimate and then legitimate again. She had every reason to be adrift. Instead she built a life. A quiet one, an enclosed one, but hers.
She wasn’t the only one. Her mother, Elizabeth Woodville, who had been queen twice and lost her sons in the Tower, ended her days at Bermondsey Abbey. (If you want more on Bridget and her sisters, I wrote about the York daughters too.)
Did nuns want to leave when the convents closed?
This is the part that I think reframes the whole story. When Thomas Cromwell’s commissioners visited the convents before the dissolution, they were supposed to be looking for immorality and corruption to justify shutting everything down. They asked the nuns, one by one, if they wanted to leave. And virtually none of them said yes.
These were not women waiting to be rescued. Prioresses fought to keep their houses open. Some paid Cromwell off, which bought them a year or two. Some were defended by their neighbors, who relied on the convent for schooling, medical care, charity and hospitality. And the commissioners often didn’t find much of the corruption they were looking for. They found communities of women who had built their lives there and didn’t want to go.
What happened to nuns after the dissolution of the monasteries?
We usually tell the dissolution as a religious story. Henry breaks with Rome, the monasteries close, the Reformation happens. That’s all true. But for women it meant something else as well. It wiped out the one institution that had given them an alternative to marriage. Between 1536 and 1541, Henry VIII closed more than 800 religious houses, and at the peak around 50 a month were being dissolved.
Monks at least had somewhere to go. They could become priests in the new Church of England, or teachers, chaplains or apothecaries. Nuns had no equivalent path, because the Church of England didn’t have nuns. The pensions were a bad joke. When Dartford surrendered, the prioress got about £66 a year, which sounds fine until you factor in the inflation of the 1540s and remember it never went up. A junior nun at Dartford got 100 shillings a year, which would have been really hard to live on within a decade, and nobody was topping it up.
And the detail that makes me angry every single time is that they weren’t allowed to marry. The Act of Six Articles in 1539 banned former monks and nuns from marrying. So they couldn’t stay in their convents, they couldn’t become clergy, and they couldn’t marry. Henry VIII had set things up so there was essentially no good outcome for the women he was throwing out.
The culture shifted too. Before the dissolution, a woman who chose not to marry had a place and a status and a community. Afterwards, celibacy became vaguely suspicious, and a woman who didn’t marry was failing at her main job in society. Convents had also provided some of the only education for girls in England, and after 1540 that was just gone, and it didn’t come back in any real way for a long time.
What happened to Dartford Priory?
Henry demolished it and built himself a palace on the same ground. Bridget’s grave was probably destroyed in the process, and we don’t know where she lies now. The gatehouse from Henry’s palace is still standing, and these days it’s used for wedding receptions. I’m not making that up.
I think we tend to read women’s history as a rescue story. Women were oppressed, some of them got rescued or rescued themselves, and that’s the happy part. The convent fits badly into that, because from the outside it looks like the thing women needed rescuing from. But what I keep coming back to is that when they were given the chance to leave, they didn’t want to. Bridget turned down a Scottish prince. The nuns of Dartford were asked if they wanted out, and they said no. These weren’t passive women. They looked at what the world outside offered, they looked at what the convent offered, and they made their choice.
Bridget missed the dissolution by about 20 years, which is probably the best thing that could have happened for her. She found her place and she kept it, and it was hers until the end.
If convents weren’t for you either, there was a third option on the continent. Meet the Beguines, the medieval women who refused to be nuns or wives and kept it up for 800 years.
Would you have liked life in a convent? I think I could have dealt with it, honestly. Tell me in the comments on the video. And if you love stories like this, I send one to your inbox every week. Sign up for the newsletter here.




